| Platinum | Farmers Butcher Shop |
| Gold | Nesbitts Meat Market |
| Gold | Nonno Luigi's Country Meats |
| Silver | Bobcaygeon Butcher Shop |
| Bronze | McQuaid's Country Market |
| Top Pick | Hillview Farm Custom Meats |
| Top Pick | Kay's Country Market |
| Top Pick | Over The Top Cattle Company |
| Top Pick | Ron Hall Meats |
| Top Pick | Strang's Valu-Mart |