| Platinum | Woodville Century House Pizza |
| Gold | Crusty Pizza |
| Gold | Formerly Tony's |
| Gold | Slices N' Scoops |
| Silver | Jacked Up Pizza |
| Silver | Pizza Hut Lindsay |
| Bronze | Luigi's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Godfather's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Gyros And Pizza Express |
| Top Pick | Papa's Pizzaland |
| Top Pick | Pizza Alloro |