| Platinum | Salvation Army Fenelon Falls |
| Gold | Vickys Value |
| Silver | Preloved Thrift Woodville |
| Bronze | Fenelon Marketplace |
| Top Pick | A Buy & Sell Shop |
| Top Pick | Hop 2 & Consign |
| Top Pick | Kawartha Collectibles & Antiques |
| Top Pick | Mission Thrift Store |
| Top Pick | Treasurers On 35 |